The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled on November 9, 2026, that California likely cannot force large companies to disclose the greenhouse gas emissions embedded in their supply chains, blocking the Scope 3 provisions of California’s Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act (SB 253) and the entirety of California’s Climate-Related Financial Risk Act (SB 261) on First Amendment grounds. The panel left SB 253’s Scope 1 and Scope 2 reporting requirements in place, including the November 10, 2026, deadline the California Air Resources Board (CARB) had already set for the law’s first reporting cycle. For the embodied carbon side of the materials market, the ruling removes, for now, the clearest mechanism that was pushing developers, building owners, and material buyers toward demanding Environmental Product Declaration (EPD) data from suppliers.

What the court decided

The case, Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America v. Sanchez, reached the Ninth Circuit after the district court denied a preliminary injunction against both laws. The panel split the analysis by treating different disclosures as different categories of speech. Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions data, which covers a company’s direct operations and purchased energy, qualified as commercial speech under the Central Hudson framework because it bears on investment, lending, and insurance decisions. Applying intermediate scrutiny, the court found California had a substantial interest in reducing information asymmetries for investors and upheld the requirement.

Scope 3 data was different. Because it describes the conduct of a company’s suppliers and customers rather than the company itself, the court treated it as noncommercial speech subject to strict scrutiny, the higher bar. California had not shown the mandate was narrowly tailored, the panel found, pointing to the state’s own reliance on third-party estimates and industry averages, the absence of evidence that mandatory reporting would be more accurate than voluntary disclosure, and insufficient proof the requirement would reduce emissions. SB 261’s climate-risk disclosures failed for a related reason: they compel companies to make predictive, contested judgments about climate risk, which the court treated as noncommercial speech with no adequate substitute for less restrictive alternatives such as voluntary reporting. The panel sent the case back to the district court to decide whether Scope 3 can be severed from the rest of SB 253 or whether the whole statute is now in question. Judge Mark Bennett, concurring in part and dissenting in part, argued Scope 1 and Scope 2 should have been enjoined as well, calling all of it noncommercial speech.

Why the materials market should care

SB 253 covers companies formed under U.S. law with more than $1 billion in global annual revenue that do business in California, a definition that reaches far beyond companies headquartered there. CARB had previewed, in workshops this past summer, that the 2027 Scope 3 cycle would make five of the 15 Scope 3 categories mandatory, including Category 1, purchased goods and services. For a real estate developer, a REIT, or a retailer with a large store-build program, Category 1 is largely a materials question: concrete, steel, insulation, and other inputs bought to build and fit out space. Scope 3 emissions account for roughly 90% of the average real estate firm’s carbon footprint, far higher than the 75% CDP estimates across sectors generally, which is why commercial real estate groups were watching the Scope 3 timeline even though the rule was never specific to construction.

That connection is why the ruling matters to specifiers and material producers who have spent the past two years anticipating demand for verified EPD data. A developer required to report Category 1 emissions has a direct reason to ask concrete and steel suppliers for product-specific EPDs rather than industry averages, because better data lowers a reported number that regulators, lenders, and tenants can see. With Scope 3 enjoined pending the district court’s severability ruling, that direct financial reason to chase EPD-backed procurement has weakened, at least until the litigation resolves or another jurisdiction fills the gap.

A supply chain that was not ready anyway

Even before the ruling, the voluntary side of embodied carbon reporting showed how far the data pipeline has to go. The American Institute of Architects (AIA) released its 2025 By the Numbers report on its 2030 Commitment program in late September, covering the 2025 reporting year across 458 signatory firms and 24,286 projects totaling 3.4 billion square feet. Only 137 of those firms, about 30%, reported embodied carbon data at all, covering 6,981 projects, about 29% of the total. That is down from roughly 9,204 embodied carbon projects in the prior year’s report. AIA attributes the drop mainly to a new reporting interface aligned with the Embodied Carbon Harmonization and Optimization (ECHO) Project, a Carbon Leadership Forum-convened effort to standardize how embodied carbon data is defined and collected across the industry, and expects reporting to recover as firms adjust. Office and mixed-use projects made up most of what firms reported, and two tools, Tally and c.scale, dominated the modeling.

Operational energy reporting in the same AIA data set is far more mature, with 67% of whole-building square footage energy modeled. Embodied carbon reporting lags well behind that, and the report does not yet publish an aggregate reduction figure for embodied carbon the way it does for predicted energy use intensity. Whatever the fate of SB 253’s Scope 3 provisions, that maturity gap was already the binding constraint on how fast large buyers could get reliable product-level data, mandate or not.

What stays in force

None of this changes the patchwork of state procurement and building code rules that already require embodied carbon data independent of corporate climate disclosure law. Those programs set purchasing or code thresholds project by project rather than asking a parent company to aggregate emissions across its entire value chain, and they are unaffected by a ruling about compelled corporate speech. The Ninth Circuit’s decision is specifically about disclosure mandates aimed at investors and the public, not about what a public owner can require of a contractor on a given job.

What to watch now

The district court’s severability ruling is the next concrete milestone, since it will determine whether SB 253’s Scope 1 and Scope 2 provisions can keep operating as a freestanding law or whether the entire statute is reopened. California can also seek rehearing en banc or petition the U.S. Supreme Court, either of which would extend the uncertainty well into 2027. CARB has not yet said how it will handle guidance for the Scope 3 cycle it had been designing, and material suppliers that were building out EPD programs in anticipation of buyer demand should treat that demand as delayed rather than canceled, since the underlying economics, reporting frameworks like ECHO, and state procurement rules that already require the data have not gone anywhere. Sustainability officers at companies that cleared the November 10 deadline for Scope 1 and Scope 2 should keep that program running regardless of the appeal, and should not assume the Scope 3 pause buys permanent cover from clients, lenders, or rating agencies that are already asking for supply chain data on their own.