The biggest obstacle to mass timber’s growth is no longer code approval. It is the cost and availability of insurance, and the industry’s response has shifted in the past eight months from complaints to concrete tools. The Climate Smart Buildings Alliance (CSBA) and the Canadian Wood Council (CWC), which jointly run Canada’s Mass Timber Insurance Action Plan, published a Phase 1 report in March 2026 showing that course of construction coverage for mass timber projects runs four to 10 times higher than for comparable concrete or steel buildings, and that some projects struggle to find coverage at any price. The report traced the gap to four causes: thin claims data, little insurer focused research, uneven contractor experience and constrained underwriting capacity, not to any settled judgment that mass timber is inherently riskier to insure.
That framing matters for specifiers and developers who have treated insurance as a line item to negotiate late in a project. It is now a design and procurement variable from day one, and the parties trying to fix it, brokers, a Canadian industry coalition and a UK research consortium, are moving in parallel rather than waiting on each other.
What the Phase 1 pilots actually produced
CSBA’s action plan ran four pilots starting in January 2025. A data trust pilot, meant to let insurers and contractors pool incident data below the claims threshold, found little near term appetite among either group and was shelved for a lighter approach. A research strategy pilot produced 12 priority research topics and a concept for a four-storey Mass Timber Testing and Training Facility in southern Ontario, still unfunded as of the report. The two pilots that moved furthest address underwriting mechanics directly. Bespoke Metrics, a contractor risk rating firm, built a Mass Timber Modifier into its general contractor scoring system after public comment in the fall of 2025, and launched the methodology publicly on March 16, 2026, giving insurers a standardized way to weigh a contractor’s specific mass timber experience rather than treating all wood construction as equivalent risk. Separately, CSBA proposed a government backed insurance captive that would absorb the first $2 million of risk on qualifying projects, intended to free up private insurers’ capacity rather than replace it. CSBA says it is still in discussions with federal and provincial governments on that proposal, and no government has committed funding as of this writing.
The Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC), the trade association for Canadian property and casualty insurers, put its own data behind the caution. In an April 23, 2026 policy brief, IBC said limited long-term performance data, unclear outcomes from moisture and water related incidents, and uncertain repair and replacement costs after fire or other damage all make mass timber harder to model than concrete or steel, where decades of loss history exist. IBC also flagged constrained reinsurance capacity for mid- and high-rise mass timber projects specifically, which limits what primary insurers can offer regardless of how well a given project is designed. Natural Resources Canada’s own tracking, cited in the brief, counts more than 850 mass timber projects and nearly 20 manufacturing facilities nationwide, concentrated in British Columbia, Ontario, Quebec and Alberta, evidence that volume is outrunning the data insurers would need to price it with confidence.
What the brokers are telling clients
Aon, a global insurance broker active in mass timber placement, published an updated assessment on October 22, 2026 arguing that the underwriting conversation has genuinely advanced since 2025 without resolving the underlying barriers. The broker pointed to fire testing in the UK and France that produced encouraging results but underscored that performance depends on the whole assembly: detailing, passive protection, construction quality and post-fire cooling all affect outcomes, and questions about smouldering and reignition in charred timber remain open. Aon said insurers are increasingly asking project teams how trapped sprinkler water would be detected and dried out, what a credible repair path looks like, and how business interruption exposure would be handled if a floor had to be replaced. The broker’s advice to clients was to use the currently softer insurance market, which it said has improved pricing and capacity in some regions, to invest in moisture management and recovery planning rather than treating favorable terms as evidence that the underlying risk has dropped. Separately, Zurich North America’s Excess & Surplus unit raised its builders risk capacity for mass timber projects from $50 million to $75 million per project in 2025, a response to broker demand that the company said it paired with continued underwriting discipline and project by project risk engineering rather than a blanket loosening of terms.
A parallel research push in the UK
The Alliance for Sustainable Building Products, a UK nonprofit that produced an early mass timber insurance playbook, launched a 14 month project in January 2026, funded by the Built by Nature foundation with co-funding from RISCAuthority and the Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification UK, to standardize how damage from fire, water, moisture and rot is assessed and repaired in mass timber buildings. The project’s stated goal is to let insurers define acceptable repair approaches before a loss occurs, rather than negotiating them case by case after one, and it is due to deliver its findings at a launch event in spring 2027. The work is proceeding alongside a separate and unresolved fight in England over a proposed revision to Approved Document B, the national fire safety guidance, that would cap exposed structural timber at 11 meters in most building types. Architects, engineers and the playbook’s own authors argued in submissions to the Health and Safety Executive’s consultation, which closed for comment on July 1, 2026, that the proposed cap is broader than the fire evidence supports and would stall the country’s mass timber pipeline. No decision had been issued as of this writing.
What to watch
US specifiers and developers should track three things over the next two quarters. First, whether Bespoke Metrics’ Mass Timber Modifier gets adopted by US focused insurers and brokers, not just Canadian ones, since a standardized contractor score would directly affect what a US project pays and how fast it gets a quote. Second, whether any Canadian government commits funding to the proposed insurance captive, which would be the first direct government backstop for mass timber risk in North America and a template other jurisdictions could copy. Third, whether the proposed Mass Timber Testing and Training Facility in Ontario secures funding, since it is the piece of the Phase 1 work most directly aimed at generating the loss and performance data that Aon, IBC and Zurich have all said insurers are waiting for. None of this changes what a project needs to do now: document contractor mass timber experience early, build moisture detection and a credible repair path into the design rather than the punch list, and bring a broker into the budget conversation before value engineering forces the issue.